Edith Hall has written a life of a woman who never lived, and The New Yorker’s review of it lands on an awkward point: we keep trying to treat Medea as a case file.

The Clinical Reflex
When a mother kills her children, the public reaches for a diagnosis. Postpartum psychosis, a depressive collapse, a mind that broke under load. The instinct is humane, and in a hospital or a courtroom it is often the right one. The review of Medea: A Life, in the magazine’s November 23, 2026 issue, makes a narrower claim: those therapeutic categories obscure what the Greeks understood about tragedy.
A diagnosis closes a case. Tragedy keeps it open.
The difference is practical. A clinical explanation puts the cause inside one person’s head and implies that the event was a malfunction. It also implies that someone could have noticed the warning signs and intervened, and that the right treatment would have prevented it. That is a comforting structure because it makes the horror something other than ordinary human capacity. The Greek stage worked the other way around, treating the act as the outcome of a situation with its own logic, a logic an audience could follow all the way to the end and still be appalled.
The book’s subtitle matters here. A “life” is a biographical form, and biography runs on cause and effect: childhood, formation, rupture, aftermath. Applying it to a figure of myth is a deliberate choice, since Medea’s existence is entirely literary. She has been rewritten by playwrights, poets and filmmakers for some twenty-five centuries, and each version has had to decide what kind of woman she is. The clinical answer is only the most recent one on offer.
What Euripides Put on the Stage
Euripides’ Medea was staged in 431 BCE at the City Dionysia in Athens, and it took third place, behind Euphorion and Sophocles. The play that became the template for every later Medea lost the contest. Athenian judges did not recognize it as the best thing on offer that year, which is worth remembering before anyone calls it inevitable.
The setup is specific. Medea comes from Colchis, at the edge of the known world. She helped Jason win the Golden Fleece and left her homeland behind for him, and in the tradition she did terrible things to her own family along the way. In Corinth, Jason abandons her to marry Glauce, the daughter of King Creon. She is a foreign woman with no city, no kin and no legal standing, and the man who owes her everything has traded her for a better connection. Euripides gives her a speech about the condition of women, including the line that she would rather stand three times in the battle line than give birth once. Her grievance is argued, not merely felt.
What follows is not the behavior of someone out of her mind. Medea talks Creon into granting her one more day in Corinth. She secures a promise of refuge from Aegeus, king of Athens, before she commits to anything. Then she sends Glauce a poisoned robe and crown, and both Glauce and Creon die. Every step is planned and sequenced. A clinician looking for a break from reality would find instead a woman who is thinking unusually well.

The children are the hard part, and Euripides does not make it easy on her or on us. Medea wavers aloud. She addresses her own heart, changes her mind, changes it back, and finally says that her anger is stronger than her deliberations. That is not the language of someone who cannot understand what she is doing. It describes someone who understands completely and does it anyway. A diagnosis says she could not help it, whereas the play says she saw it clearly, and that is the version that leaves no exit for the audience.
Then Euripides withholds the ending we expect. Medea does not get arrested, judged or cured. She leaves Corinth in a chariot sent by Helios, her grandfather the sun god, while Jason is left with nothing and no one. The clinical frame wants a recovery or a sentence, some institutional closure. The Greek play offers neither, and the omission seems to be the point.
What Gets Lost When Every Medea Is a Case
The cost of the clinical reflex is a loss of range. If every mother who kills her children is a patient, we lose the ability to hold a more uncomfortable thought: that intelligence, legitimate grievance and cruelty can sit in the same person at the same time. Tragedy is built to keep that thought in view. The review’s subhead says forgetting this is done “at our peril,” and the peril is a culture that can only process its worst events by shrinking them.

None of this argues against treatment, or against the doctors and juries who deal with real cases. It argues that explanation and understanding are different jobs, and that one can crowd out the other. Euripides left Medea in the sky, in a borrowed chariot, with two dead sons behind her. What would a file on her even say?






