Jennifer Maritza McCauley usually asks the questions. As a co-host of the Fiction/Non/Fiction podcast, she sits on the interviewer’s side of the microphone. For this episode she moves across it to talk about her forthcoming short story collection, Recognition, with V.V. Ganeshananthan and Whitney Terrell.
The conversation covers a lot of ground for one episode: family history, nonfiction reshaped into fiction, a psychoanalytic theory of the self, the mechanics of academic publishing, and a story about a screenwriter being used as cover by a Hollywood producer. McCauley, a multigenre writer, also reads from two stories, “Home Ghosts” and “Black Planet.”

A Co-Host Takes the Guest Seat
The episode is built around the book, but it also works as a tour of how McCauley thinks about writing. She discusses how the collection connects to her earlier volume, When Trying to Return Home. She talks about writing on race and pop culture. And she describes what it was like to publish with an academic press, a route that meant the manuscript went through peer review.
The show notes read like a syllabus. Her other titles are listed, including Scar On / Scar Off and Neon Steel, along with the title story “Recognition,” which ran in Wigleaf. The outside references run from Jacques Lacan’s essay “The Mirror-Phase as Formative of the Function of the I” (New Left Review I/51, September-October 1968) to Borges’s “Four Cycles,” Percival Everett’s Erasure, John Gardner’s The Art of Fiction, and a Kurt Vonnegut video on the shape of stories. Public Enemy’s Fear of a Black Planet also makes the list, which makes sense given the title of one of the stories she reads.
Family History, Rewritten as Fiction
One thread McCauley follows is the movement from nonfiction into fiction, drawing on her own family’s history. In the collection’s family stories, the relatives who appear are not just background. Ganeshananthan describes the character Aya’s family as knitting the stories together, a connective tissue that runs through the book and lets individual pieces echo each other.
That structure ties into the book’s governing idea. McCauley discusses how Lacan’s mirror stage shapes the collection. In Lacan’s account, a person first assembles a sense of an “I” by recognizing an image of themselves from outside. A collection titled Recognition can use that idea at several scales. A character can look at a relative and see herself, or look at a movie screen and wonder whether she appears on it at all.
Ganeshananthan makes that distinction in her question. Alongside the family stories, she says, there are moments where characters look at culture and either see themselves represented or try to. Film is the most frequent mirror, and race is what complicates the reflection. The family stories and the culture stories pose the same question from different angles: who counts as seen, and by whom?
The collection also has a predecessor. McCauley links it to When Trying to Return Home, so readers who know the earlier book will find the new one in conversation with it. She also reads from “Home Ghosts,” a title that suggests the family material in the book, though the excerpt published with the episode is from a different story.

The Producer, the Screenwriter, and the Staff Photo
The excerpt printed alongside the episode comes from “Black Planet,” which Ganeshananthan calls one of her two favorite stories in the collection and “hysterically funny.” Its protagonist is a Black and Puerto Rican screenwriter named Marcus, whom one character calls Malcolm. He interviews with a producer named Galvin, or Gal, who is white or at least white-presenting and claims to be part Black and Indigenous.
McCauley says the story takes jabs at a lot of people, journalists included, but that it is also meant as a realistic look at Hollywood practices. The scene she reads comes after a long conversation about race and about the show Galvin wants to run: a series about Orishas wielding Samurai swords. Marcus is not buying it. The energy has soured, and Galvin is trying to wrap up.
What Galvin Actually Wants
Galvin slides back into what the story calls his “most pleasing self” and drops the pretense. He tells Marcus he doesn’t really need him to write anything. He needs ideas, and he needs Marcus to be there. If the show comes under fire, Galvin says, he can point out that he has “a Black Latino staff.” Writing is optional, and the job is to supply the optics.
The story’s narration answers in Marcus’s head. Being in the photo shoot, he thinks, was not usually how a writers’ room worked. Marcus has degrees in the craft. He had written for projects before depression hit him, and he knew how to write. That line gives the scene its sting. Galvin’s offer is insulting because of what it takes from a man with real credentials, not only because it is cynical. It ties back to the collection’s title: Galvin wants Marcus recognized as a prop, not as a writer.
Peer Review and a Long Reading List
The episode also gets practical about publishing. McCauley discusses the experience of working with an academic press, where a manuscript goes through peer review, an unusual step for a short story collection. Most fiction writers never face that kind of scrutiny before publication.
The conversation sits in a longer relationship between McCauley and the show. The notes point listeners to Season 10, Episode 2, the ten-year anniversary episode, and to Season 8, Episode 6, where she discussed Puerto Ricans, Trump, and the election. The episode is produced by Ganeshananthan, Terrell, AJ Abernathy, Sienna Hoopingarner, and Grace Workman. Listeners can subscribe on iTunes, Google Play, Stitcher, Spotify, or another podcast app, searching with the forward slashes included in the show’s name, or stream it from the player. Video versions are on the show’s Instagram account, its YouTube channel, and the website at fnfpodcast.net.

Still, the most memorable image from the episode is a small one: a producer telling a writer he doesn’t need him to write. Marcus, as McCauley puts it, knows how.






